California Residency Planning Still Matters
California’s billionaire tax has been defeated, but the tax exposure facing high earners remains. Preliminary returns show Proposition 40 losing by roughly 53% to 47%, while Proposition 42, which would restrict future wealth taxes, leads. Results are not yet certified; the certification deadline is December 11, 2026.[1]
For business owners, executives and investors, the continuing issue is California’s top 13.3% income tax rate. A move may reduce that exposure, but only if the facts support nonresidency and the income is not California-source. My nearly 13 years as an attorney with the Franchise Tax Board (FTB”), followed by private practice, inform the practical lessons below.
What the vote changed
Proposition 40 would have imposed a one-time tax of up to 5% on roughly 200 billionaires. It tied residency to January 1, 2026, and wealth to December 31, 2026, with payment in a lump sum or five annual installments at additional cost. Moving after the residency date would not have avoided it. Proposition 42 would prohibit new taxes on financial assets, business holdings and other personal property, and most retroactive taxes.[2]
Those protections would not be permanent: voters could change them later. In fact, the sponsoring healthcare union has threatened another measure in 2028 if Sacramento does not address federal healthcare funding cuts. Four earlier wealth-tax legislative efforts since 2020 also failed.[3]
Income taxes have fared differently. Voters approved the 1% millionaire surcharge in 2004, generating billions annually, and higher “temporary” rates in 2012, extended them in 2016, and have now approved Proposition 3 to remove their 2031 sunset. The wealth-tax defeat does not undo those taxes.[4]
What residency means for your tax bill
Residents pay California tax on worldwide income; nonresidents pay on California-source income. The top marginal rate is 13.3%, including the 1% surcharge on taxable income above $1 million. For wages subject to state disability insurance, the combined marginal burden can reach 14.6% in 2026. California gives capital gains no preferential rate. At 13.3%, a $20 million gain represents about $2.66 million in state tax—a top-rate illustration, not an exact calculation.[5]
California treats you as a resident if you are here for other than a temporary or transitory purpose, or if you are domiciled here and leave for a temporary or transitory purpose. A vacation, brief business trip or short assignment generally does not change residency. Purpose, duration and personal and business ties matter more than a simple day count.[6]
Your domicile is your permanent home—the place you intend to return to. It continues until you abandon it and establish another. Residency also examines your closest connections: homes and their use, spouse and children, work, doctors, advisors and other meaningful relationships. No single factor controls. An FTB residency determination is presumed correct; the taxpayer must overcome it with evidence.[7]
What the FTB actually looks at
A new address is only the beginning. Four common shortcuts can leave substantial exposure:
The 183-day myth. California has no general 183-day residency rule. More than nine months here creates a rebuttable presumption of residency; less time creates no presumption of nonresidency. You can remain a resident with little or no physical presence in the state.[8]
The paperwork myth. An out-of-state driver’s license and voter registration help document a move, but do not outweigh stronger evidence that your life remains centered in California.
The second-home myth. The acquisition of a second residence does not in and of itself establish a change of residency. In Appeal of Bracamonte, the taxpayers began moving to Nevada in February 2008 and sold their business on July 18. They rented a Nevada apartment but kept their California home and spent 90 days in California versus 28 in Nevada during the relevant period. The Office of Tax Appeals (“OTA”) found them residents when the sale closed; the FTB conceded a domicile change only as of September 29.[9]
The intent myth. Statements about moving carry less weight than objective conduct reflected in calendars, credit-card transactions and phone records. A defensible permanent move requires meaningful changes in California ties and a new home that actually becomes the center of your life.[10]
How residency audits unfold
An audit reconstructs your life after the move through calendars, financial transactions, travel records and other evidence. A large gain in the year of a first nonresident or part-year return raises a central question: did residency end before the gain arose? A retained home or California addresses on K-1s, brokerage statements and insurance policies can complicate the answer.
The FTB generally has four years from the original return due date or actual filing date, whichever is later, to propose an assessment, subject to exceptions. If no return was filed, it may assess at any time. An adverse determination can expose worldwide income during residency to tax, interest and potential penalties. Interest generally runs from the original payment due date and compounds daily, potentially erasing the expected savings.[11]
Left over the wealth tax and thinking of returning
A quick return—especially to a home you kept available—can support an argument that your absence was temporary and residency never ended. In Appeal of Mazer, a taxpayer took a two-year job in Malaysia while his wife remained in their California home. He returned after 13 months. The OTA held that he remained a resident and his Malaysian earnings were taxable here. His absence also fell short of the 546-day employment-contract safe harbor, which has additional restrictions.[12]
Returning does not automatically invalidate a genuine departure. The question is whether the evidence supports the intervening period of nonresidency. A short absence surrounding a large gain makes your reasons for leaving and returning especially important. Review the departure and supporting records before moving back.
Income that can remain taxable after a move
Even a successful relocation does not eliminate California-source income. Rent and gains from California real estate remain taxable. Business income attributable to California activities can remain taxable, as can gain from the sale of a business, depending on the transaction structure, assets and sourcing rules. Options exercised or restricted stock vesting after departure may still produce California-taxable compensation for services performed here; allocation depends on the award.[13]
Other rules that affect the result
A spouse who stays. A resident spouse’s share of community income can remain taxable in California even when the nonresident spouse earns it elsewhere. The applicable community property rules and the income’s character determine the result.[14]
Trusts. Since 2023, California generally requires grantors to report income from incomplete-gift non-grantor trusts—trusts sometimes used to shift state income taxation while the transfer remains incomplete for gift-tax purposes. Resident grantors generally report worldwide income; California sourcing remains relevant for nonresident grantors.[15]
Small business stock. California does not recognize the federal qualified small business stock exclusion. This matters when the gain is otherwise taxable here; it does not itself turn a nonresident’s stock gain into California-source income.[16]
Don’t let the tax tail wag the dog
A move can look better on paper than it feels in practice. If your spouse, children, business and home remain rooted in California, relocating chiefly to shelter a major gain can lead to dissatisfaction—and an early return. Remaining a resident and planning around timing, income sourcing and business structure may better serve your goals. Decide whether leaving works for your life before deciding how to leave.
What to do now
Treat a residency change with the same care as a major transaction. The plan should address your life, the income California can still tax, and the evidence supporting your departure.
Decide whether you are truly leaving. Make relocation a family and business decision. Tax savings should inform that choice, not dictate your lifestyle.
Measure exposure and plan the timing. Review your ties, expected income and any sale, public offering or vesting event as an auditor would. A move immediately before a large gain invites scrutiny. Meaningful time between relocation and the gain can help establish the facts, but no waiting period guarantees nonresidency.
Address the California home. Selling, leasing to an unrelated tenant at market terms, or keeping the home available for personal use creates materially different evidence. Decide how the home will fit into the move before claiming a new residence.
Build the record as you go. Preserve calendars, travel records and evidence of daily life. Records created at the time carry more weight than a file reconstructed after an audit begins.
Coordinate your advisors. Your CPA, estate planner, wealth manager and deal counsel should work from the same facts and timeline, with consistent returns and documents.
If you already left, review the record now. Resolve inconsistencies while evidence remains available. Ask residency counsel whether a California nonresident return is required or advisable, including how filing affects the assessment period.
The wealth-tax headline will fade. California’s income tax will remain. A defensible departure requires enough time to understand the consequences, establish a genuine relocation, and build records showing that your life moved with you.
About the author
Raul A. Escatel is a senior partner at Ascendant Law Group LLP, where he leads the tax controversy and planning group. A Certified Specialist in Taxation Law, State Bar of California Board of Legal Specialization, he served nearly 13 years as an FTB attorney. He advises high-net-worth individuals and their advisors on California residency and domicile planning and represents taxpayers in residency audits and appeals.
This article provides general education, not legal or tax advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Residency depends on individual facts. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Election information is as of November 10, 2026, and is not yet certified.
Notes and authorities
- KQED, California Election Results (Associated Press returns), Props. 3, 40 and 42 (Nov. 9–10, 2026); Prop. 40 race called Nov. 9. California Secretary of State, General Election Key Dates and Deadlines (certification Dec. 11, 2026). Election results Certification calendar
- Legislative Analyst’s Office, Proposition 40 (2026); KQED, Proposition 42 (2026). Proposition 40’s proposed tax applied to billionaires resident on Jan. 1, with wealth measured Dec. 31, 2026; estimated affected population approximately 200. Proposition 40 Proposition 42
- Grace Hase, S.G.V. Tribune (Nov. 3, 2026), reporting SEIU-UHW’s conditional 2028 pledge. Earlier failed efforts: AB 2088 (2020), 0.4% above $30 million; AB 310/ACA 8 (2021), 1% above $50 million with a higher rate above $1 billion; AB 2289 (2022), similar design; AB 259/ACA 3 (2023), 1.5% above $1 billion. The first two failed to advance through the Assembly; the latter two were held in committee. Union statement FTB AB 259 analysis
- Proposition 63 (2004), approved 53.8%–46.2%, imposed the 1% surcharge; Propositions 30 (2012) and 55 (2016) established and extended higher rates. Proposition 3 (2026) removes the sunset on the 10.3%, 11.3% and 12.3% brackets. See LAO, Proposition 3; election results in note 1. LAO analysis
- Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code (R&TC) §§ 17041, 17001.5, 17951; EDD, 2026 Contribution Rates (SDI 1.3%; no wage ceiling since 2024); FTB, 2025 Schedule D (540) Instructions. The $2.66 million example multiplies $20 million by 13.3%; actual tax depends on brackets, filing status, other income, deductions and credits. EDD rates Schedule D
- R&TC § 17014(a); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 18, § 17014(a); FTB Publication 1031, Guidelines for Determining Resident Status (2024). Temporary or transitory purpose is determined from all the circumstances. FTB Publication 1031
- Cal. Code Regs., tit. 18, § 17014(c); Appeal of Bragg, 2003-SBE-002; Appeal of Bracamonte, 2021-OTA-156P (taxpayer bears the burden by a preponderance of the evidence).
- R&TC § 17016; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 18, § 17016; Appeal of Jaffee (71-SBE-023). The nine-month presumption is rebuttable; residency may continue even without physical presence.
- Appeal of Bracamonte, 2021-OTA-156P (Nevada apartment, retained California home, comparative days, July 18 sale and Sept. 29, 2008 domicile concession). Opinion
- Noble v. Franchise Tax Board (2004) 118 Cal.App.4th 560, 567; Bracamonte, supra (objective conduct outweighs formalities and unsupported assertions). A change of domicile is distinct from nonresidency under other rules, including the employment safe harbor.
- R&TC §§ 19057(a), 19066 (general assessment period and early-filed returns), 19087(a) (unfiled returns), 19101 and 19521 (interest). Extensions and statutory exceptions can alter the general four-year period.
- Appeal of Mazer, 2020-OTA-263P; R&TC § 17014(d). The employment-contract safe harbor requires at least 546 consecutive days outside California; visits cannot exceed 45 days per taxable year. It is unavailable if intangible income exceeds $200,000 in any covered tax year or the principal purpose of the absence is tax avoidance. Opinion
- R&TC § 17951; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 18, §§ 17951-4, 17951-5; FTB Publications 1031 and 1004, Equity-Based Compensation Guidelines; FTB Residency and Sourcing Technical Manual (Jan. 2026). Equity allocation may compare California workdays with total workdays during the applicable service period.
- FTB Publication 1031, pt. M; Appeal of Cremel and Koeppel, 2021-OTA-222P; Appeal of Misskelley, 84-SBE-077. A California resident-spouse is taxed on his or her community property share of a nonresident spouse’s income; the result depends on the earning spouse’s domicile and the character of the income.
- R&TC § 17082 (tax years beginning Jan. 1, 2023, regardless of trust creation date); FTB, Incomplete Gift Non-Grantor Trusts. A limited exception applies to certain electing trusts distributing at least 90% of distributable net income to qualifying charities. FTB guidance
- IRC §§ 1202, 1045; FTB, 2025 Schedule D (540) Instructions (California does not conform to the federal qualified small business stock exclusion or rollover deferral). See note 5.


Comments are closed.